News : This Question Has Been Asked And Answered: A top exec quits a major autism group because she doesn’t think vaccines cause the disorder.

The warfare over vaccines and autism is heating up yet again. This week, Alison Singer, the executive vice president of communications and awareness at Autism Speaks, one of the nation's leading autism advocacy groups, announced her resignation, citing a difference of opinion over the organization's policy on vaccine research. "Dozens of credible scientific studies have exonerated vaccines as a cause of autism," she wrote in a statement. "I believe we must devote limited funding to more promising avenues of autism research." Singer, who has an 11-year-old daughter with autism, joined the organization when it launched in 2005. Singer praised Autism Speaks and its founders, Bob and Suzanne Wright, but said she could no longer work for a group that supports spending limited resources on vaccine research. Calling Singer's resignation "disappointing and sad," Bob Wright says more authoritative research needs to be conducted on the safety of vaccines given to children under 2. "We all know that autism has genetic causes, but it's highly associated with environmental factors we can't get our hands around," says Wright. "Vaccines fall into that category." NEWSWEEK's Claudia Kalb spoke with Alison Singer about her resignation. Excerpts:

NEWSWEEK: Describe Autism Speaks.
Alison Singer:
Autism Speaks is an amazing organization. It has really been a privilege for me to work there. Autism Speaks has raised so much awareness of autism and has supported literally thousands of families around the world. I could not be more proud of Autism Speaks and the work that we've done.

But you disagree with their vaccine position?
In general, I disagree with a policy that says, "Despite what this study shows, more studies should be done." At some point, you have to say, "This question has been asked and answered and it's time to move on." We need to be able to say, "Yes, we are now satisfied that the earth is round."

What do you believe the science shows?
There are more than a dozen studies that show no causal link between the MMR [measles-mumps-rubella] vaccine and autism, and thimerosal [a mercury-containing vaccine preservative] and autism. Over and over, the science has shown no causal link between vaccines and autism. My feeling is that if there was an unlimited pot of money at the NIH [National Institutes of Health] from which to fund autism science then it would be fine to say let's study it more. But we don't have that. We have very limited resources and every dollar we spend looking where we know the answer isn't is a dollar we don't have to spend where we might actually find new answers. In general, yes, more research is always better than less. But again, we have limited dollars to spend and we have to use our limited money wisely in ways that are likely to yield new information for families.

How confident are you in the studies that show no vaccine-autism link?
I've read the studies and I've talked to many doctors. One thing that has been a hugely wonderful part of being at Autism Speaks is that I've been able to consult with the top scientists in the field. We work with the top minds. I think that there's this feeling [among some parents] that the vaccine decision is a choice between, "Do I want to risk measles or do I want to risk autism?" That's not a good characterization. We know for a fact that the measles vaccine reduces the risk of getting measles. One choice is backed by science, one choice isn't.

Where would you like to see the research money go?
I think the genetics work has the potential to point us toward important answers. When we can determine which proteins are associated with various genes we can start to understand the mechanism of action that causes autism. Once you understand the mechanism of action, you can start to look for targeted therapies. I would also focus on prenatal exposures. What is a mom exposed to during pregnancy with regard to hormones or maybe medications or even pesticides? Or what's happening in the environment? During flu season, people are more prone to infections so we should look at the incidence of viral infections, flu, hormonal fluctuations and toxins in the environment for both mother and baby.

How is your daughter doing now?
Jodie has benefited tremendously from applied behavioral analysis therapy. She has learned to have some actual communicative speech. She's able to make her wants and needs known. That's really a breakthrough. For three years, she was in private school that focused intensively on language. She gained enough skills to be in a special class in a public middle school. She's not mainstreamed, but she's able to be in that large environment. So she's making great progress.

What do you think caused your daughter's autism?
Jodie had difficulties from the day she was born. She cried constantly, she had difficulty feeding, difficulty sleeping. She was diagnosed in the first few days as having "failure to thrive." I also have a brother diagnosed with autism. He's 44. My first cousin has a son diagnosed with autism. I strongly believe that there is a genetic component.

What do you say to the families who believe their child's autism was triggered by vaccines?
It's very hard because people feel very strongly and love their families so much. But not all opinions are created equal. Some are based on fact and science and some are not. Do you remember when Jenny McCarthy went on Oprah? She said she doesn't need science. Her science is at home and his name is Evan. That's not science.

Here's another story. A few weeks ago, Jodie went to the pediatrician. She had Tdap [tetanus-diptheria-pertussis] vaccine, a flu shot and a vaccine against meningitis. The next day her teacher remarked to me that Jodie was much more attentive and participated in class much more than usual. Her gym teacher said that for the fist time Jodie was able to compete in an obstacle course. Should I start pontificating that vaccines are a great treatment for autism? Of course not, that's not science. That's called coincidence.

Some families want more money spent on services for people with autism. Thoughts?
I think that's true. There's a growing number of people with autism and they're going to need services and supports. We really need to think about autism as a lifespan issue. We need to start planning now for our children's future.

placeAd2(commercialNode,'bigbox',false,'') What about federal health officials? Some scientists have critiqued them for not being outspoken enough about vaccine safety. Do you agree?
I think the media has to start to change. In our culture, we love celebrities. We need to listen to experts and not actresses. The media culture, feeling compelled to give both sides of an argument has lent a legitimacy to the anti-vaccine movement that is very over-weighted. They're a small number of people with very loud voices. The vast majority of parents of children with autism are very supportive of the importance of vaccines. I've had hundreds of emails in last 24 hours from parents supporting me. The media need to show both sides to make it look like both sides are equal. One side is backed by evidence, one side is not.

I think the government needs to be more vocal and I think scientists have to be more vocal. Scientists are an interesting group. They are very reluctant to speak to the media. There needs to be change in that culture. Scientists need to be more comfortable speaking out about the good science being done. I think when we see the scientists speaking out more, we will see a change.

In an interview in 2006, you said, "I am planning to stay at Autism Speaks until the day we find a cure." Now what?
Now I'll revise that to say I plan to stay in autism advocacy. I plan to take all the energy and passion that I committed to Autism Speaks and apply it elsewhere in the autism advocacy community. I'm certainly not going to be leaving. If anything, I hope to be more vocal.

Will you become more vocal on the vaccine issue specifically?
I think by talking to you today I already have.

News Article Archives

5.16.2012 NY Times: A Mathematical Challenge to Obesity  3 days ago days ago
4.12.2012 Summer Newsletter Now Available  37 days ago days ago
4.5.2012 Reminder: Good Friday Schedule  44 days ago days ago
3.26.2012 School/Camp Form Guidelines  54 days ago days ago
*UPDATE* 3.21.2012 Blue Fish Pediatrics Closing at Noon for Good Friday  59 days ago days ago
*UPDATE* 2.23.2012 ATT & Verizon Reaching Cypress Phone Lines  86 days ago days ago
2.1.2012 A.A.P. Article: AAP Expands Guidelines for Infant Sleep Safety and SIDS Risk Reduction  108 days ago days ago
2.1.2012 N.Y. Times Article: Children’s A.D.D. Drugs….  108 days ago days ago
1.30.2012 HealthyChildren.org and KidsDoc App  110 days ago days ago
*UPDATE* 1.10.2012 Power Back Up at Blue Fish Memorial  130 days ago days ago
1.10.2012 Power Outages @ Memorial  130 days ago days ago
11.30.2011 Christmas and New Years Office Schedule  171 days ago days ago
11.8.2011 Blue Fish Pediatrics Thanksgiving Schedule  193 days ago days ago
10.26.2011 Final BF Memorial Flu Clinic THIS SATURDAY!  206 days ago days ago
10.24.2011 Swaddling Your Baby  208 days ago days ago
10.20.2011 AAP EXPANDS GUIDELINES FOR INFANT SLEEP SAFETY AND SIDS RISK REDUCTION  212 days ago days ago
10.17.2011 Final Flu Clinic Saturday, October 29th  215 days ago days ago
10.17.2011 Yahoo! News: Worried about Vitamin Safety?  215 days ago days ago
10.7.2011: NY Times Post: Report Indicates an Increase in Concussion Awareness  225 days ago days ago
9.29.2011 Flu Clinic this Saturday!  233 days ago days ago
9.21.2011 While-You-Wait Express Service on School Forms  241 days ago days ago
*UPDATE* Flu Vaccine Availablity for 10/1/2011 Flu Vaccine Clinic  242 days ago days ago
9.16.2011 *UPDATE* Flu Vaccine Availability  246 days ago days ago
9.12.2011 Flu Vaccine Supply Update  250 days ago days ago
9.6.2011 Flu Clinic Paperwork Now Available  256 days ago days ago
8.30.2011 *UPDATE* FLU NEWSLETTER 2011-2012 IS HERE!  263 days ago days ago
8.25.2011: THE 2011 FLU NEWSLETTER IS HERE!  268 days ago days ago
8.25.2011 Blue Fish Pediatrics Memorial: Flu Vaccine Clinics  268 days ago days ago
7.27.2011 A Great Vaccine Information Resource  297 days ago days ago
Summer School/Camp Program Med Form Reminders  332 days ago days ago
5.26.2011 – Blue Fish Pediatrics Closed for Memorial Day  359 days ago days ago
5.17.2011 BF Summer Newsletter Now Available!  368 days ago days ago
5.10.2011 Summer Forms Reminder  375 days ago days ago
3.29.2011 BF Memorial Phones to Go Down for Maintenance  417 days ago days ago
3.23.2011 **UPDATE** BF Phones Back Up!  423 days ago days ago
3.23.2011 **UPDATE** BF Memorial Phones Partially Up  423 days ago days ago
3.22.2011 **URGENT** BF MEMORIAL PHONES DOWN  424 days ago days ago
3.22.2011 NYT: Rear-Facing Car Seats Advised at Least to Age of 2  424 days ago days ago
3.3.2011 WSJ: Sweating Out a Fever  443 days ago days ago
3.3.2011 Another Reason Why We Do Not Recommend Cough and Cold Medications.  443 days ago days ago
2.23.2011 Blue Fish and E-Prescribing  451 days ago days ago
2.9.2011 URGENT MESSAGE: RESCHEDULING WELL CHECKUPS DUE TO ICY WEATHER  465 days ago days ago
2.4.2011 *UPDATE* Blue Fish Memorial City Open for Sick Visits  470 days ago days ago
2.4.2011 Blue Fish Pediatrics Closed Friday Morning  471 days ago days ago
1.26.2011 CDC Offers Flu Guide for Parents  479 days ago days ago
NYT: Lifting a Veil of Fear to See a Few Benefits of Fever  492 days ago days ago
LA Times: MMR Vaccine/Autism Link Study a “fraud”  499 days ago days ago
NYT: Remedies: Honey for Coughing  500 days ago days ago
NYT: With Kids and Coffee Tables, It’s Trip, Fall, Ouch  503 days ago days ago
Sign Up for BF Pediatrics Newsletter Today!  528 days ago days ago
12.1.2010 Report Questions Need for Vitamin D Supplement  535 days ago days ago
BF Cypress: Meet the Doctors Night – Dec. 9th  536 days ago days ago
9.10.2010 More Details on our Saturday Flu Clinics  617 days ago days ago
9.9.2010 Flu Clinic Information Packet Available  618 days ago days ago
8.30.2010 Flu Vaccine Information Newsletter Available  628 days ago days ago
8.30.2010 Flu Vaccine Information Newsletter Available  628 days ago days ago
8.26.2010 Upcoming Flu Clinic Dates  632 days ago days ago
8.26.2010 Upcoming Flu Clinic Dates  632 days ago days ago
8.23.2010 Blue Fish Cypress Coming Soon!  635 days ago days ago
8.23.2010 Blue Fish Cypress Coming Soon!  635 days ago days ago
NY TIMES: Breast Feeding Research  652 days ago days ago
NY TIMES: Breast Feeding Research  656 days ago days ago
AAP Updates Guidelines for Infectious Disease Exclusions  683 days ago days ago
New York Times: Whooping Cough  694 days ago days ago
Summer Newsletter 2010  722 days ago days ago
Wall Street Journal: No Benefit in Delayed Immunization  723 days ago days ago
5.26.2010 Blue Fish Closed for Memorial Day  724 days ago days ago
NY TIMES: Top 10 Biggest Choking Hazards  724 days ago days ago
PCV Vaccine Update 5.11.10  739 days ago days ago
Blue Fish Will Close at Noon for Good Friday  779 days ago days ago
3.23.2010 GSK Rotovirus Vaccine Recall Information  788 days ago days ago
2.10.10 H1N1 Flu Vaccine Update  829 days ago days ago
2.4.2010: Flu Vaccine Availability Anouncement  835 days ago days ago
Doctor in MMR-Autism Scare Ruled Unethical  836 days ago days ago
Booster Clinic 1.9.2010  864 days ago days ago
Office Hours during New Year’s weekend  870 days ago days ago
Office Hours During the Christmas Season  878 days ago days ago
Booster Vaccines Available 12.19.2009  883 days ago days ago
CDC: H1N1 Flu Vaccine Update  884 days ago days ago
Update on Current H1N1 Flu Vaccine Clinic 12.12.2009  889 days ago days ago
Update: Flu Clinic 12.12.2009  892 days ago days ago
Blue Fish is on Twitter!  892 days ago days ago
Upcoming H1N1 Flu Clinic 12/12  894 days ago days ago
Thanksgiving Holiday  907 days ago days ago
H1N1 Flu Vaccine Clinic 11.21.2009 Available Tickets  910 days ago days ago
Houston I.S.D. H1N1 Flu Vaccination Availability  911 days ago days ago
H1N1 Flu Vaccine Clinic 11.21.09  913 days ago days ago
H1N1 flu clinic announcement  919 days ago days ago
Booster shot schedule: For those who received 1st H1N1 vaccination at a different clinic  919 days ago days ago
Upcoming H1N1 Flu Clinic 12/12  919 days ago days ago
Stock update for the H1N1 flu vaccine  928 days ago days ago
Update for H1N1 flu vaccine clinic  929 days ago days ago
H1N1 availability  934 days ago days ago
Clarification update for H1N1 flu vaccine clinics  936 days ago days ago
H1N1 Flu Clinic  938 days ago days ago
Flu Clinic  953 days ago days ago
Local Pharmacies  961 days ago days ago
General Questions and Answers on 2009 H1N1 Influenza Vaccine Safety  962 days ago days ago
Q&A Regarding H1N1 Vaccine from NIAD  962 days ago days ago
Family Flu Day Clinic Suspension  971 days ago days ago
Family Flu Day Clinic  973 days ago days ago
Flu Newsletter  988 days ago days ago
Labor Day  988 days ago days ago
Flu Information  999 days ago days ago
Novel H1N1 Flu (Swine Flu) and You  999 days ago days ago
Centers for Disease Control (CDC) Site on H1N1  999 days ago days ago
Independence Day  1052 days ago days ago
Hib Vaccine Announcement  1052 days ago days ago
F.D.A. Warns Against Use of Popular Cold Remedy  1067 days ago days ago
Gessner Driveway Entrance Partial Closure  1087 days ago days ago
Is Vaccine Refusal Worth The Risk?  1089 days ago days ago
Swine Flu FAQ: Will getting swine flu now protect me later? Why is winter flu season? Why do vaccines take so long?  1113 days ago days ago
Flu Genes Suggest Virus Not As Deadly As 1918  1114 days ago days ago
Top 5 Swine Flu Don’ts  1114 days ago days ago
To Travel or Not to Travel? A Swine Flu Dilemma  1114 days ago days ago
Swine Flu: Information for Concerned Parents and Caregivers  1115 days ago days ago
La Influencza Porcina y Usted (gripe porcina)  1115 days ago days ago
Swine Influenza and You  1118 days ago days ago
New York Times Article on Swine Flu  1118 days ago days ago
Summer Newsletter 2009  1123 days ago days ago
Pacifiers and Breastfeeding: No Adverse Relationship Found  1136 days ago days ago
Food, Glorious Food Myths; The Perils of Fruity Drinks  1137 days ago days ago
Changes in Texas Immunization Requirements  1145 days ago days ago
This Question Has Been Asked And Answered: A top exec quits a major autism group because she doesn’t think vaccines cause the disorder.  1145 days ago days ago
School Policy for Infectious Disease Exclusions  1145 days ago days ago
Accidental Bed-Related Infant Deaths Quadruple  1145 days ago days ago
Possible Therapy Takes Bite Out of Peanut Allergy  1161 days ago days ago
Early Exposure to Peanuts May Prevent Allergy  1172 days ago days ago
Detour Notice Relating to the Gessner Road Widening Improvement Project  1180 days ago days ago
The Facts About Childhood Vaccines  1206 days ago days ago
Babies Know: A Little Dirt Is Good for You  1206 days ago days ago
Vicks VapoRub Misuse May Hurt Infants  1220 days ago days ago
Vitamin D Update  1271 days ago days ago
6 Food Mistakes Parents Make  1317 days ago days ago
FLU SEASON 2008-2009  1340 days ago days ago
How Safe Are Vaccines?  1395 days ago days ago
Blue Fish Pediatrics’ 2008 Summer Newsletter is Here!  1429 days ago days ago
No Vaccine-Autism Link in Feds’ Ruling  1475 days ago days ago
Crib bumpers in the night: a hazard to infants  1478 days ago days ago
Rear-Facing Car Safety Seats: Getting the Message Right  1478 days ago days ago
Infectious Diarrhea Pathogens Lurk at Petting Zoos, Pools  1486 days ago days ago
Website Testimonies!  1626 days ago days ago
Blue Fish Pediatrics – Flu Vaccine Stock Update  1657 days ago days ago
Treating Disease with Vitamin C and Megavitamins  1839 days ago days ago
Traveling to Developing Countries  1839 days ago days ago
H Texas Magazine’s Top Professionals on the Fast Track  1843 days ago days ago
Traveling to S.E. Asia  1843 days ago days ago
Summer Suggestions  1843 days ago days ago
Many Factors Involved In Decolonization of S. aureus  1850 days ago days ago